Why Are Brands Scared of Being Scary?

Who I think should embrace the terror.
Kennon Cummings
·
October 31, 2026

IT WAS A DARK AND STORMY NIGHT…

A young boy ventures out into the foggy maw that is the woods on the outskirts of his village. 

At this time, he’s not meant to venture this far out unmonitored, but the boy knows it’s for a valiant reason: his beloved dog had run astray under his watch. 

Suddenly, he hears a shrill whine. Following the cries of his pet, he stumbles upon something…. New.

A hole sits in the middle of the clearing. Ominous, pulsating, hungry for more. 

And suddenly— the boy is struck by a geyser…. Of tiramisu. 

…Did I mention this story is pulled straight from an overnight oats ad? 

‍

LET’S GET SCARY!!!!

Up-and-coming brand Oat Cult definitely shocked the masses with this ad showcasing their new flavored oats. It’s hard not to be surprised— amidst a wholesome, granola-girl-esque market of oatmeal products, a sinister cult-like twist sticks out like a sore thumb in the absolute best way possible. On top of the kooky, spooky vibe the brand usually sports, these borderline-horrifying ads feel novel even outside the world of breakfast food ads. 

So… why don’t we see out-of-left-field scares like this more often?

While fear is as potent an emotion as any other, it can be a feeling that’s difficult to harness effectively in advertising. Many brands can be a bit too worried about possibly scaring off potential customers with their ads, often going for safer emotional routes, like comedy or feel-good content.

I understand the worries… but honestly? It just makes me want brands to do it even more! When done effectively, you leave a lasting impression on your audience and stand out from the crowd. 

WHO SHALL JOIN THE SPOOKY ELITE?

Obviously, I need to enlist some troops to join the league of scary ads. I got three pitches for you today:

DICK’S Sporting Goods

I’m imagining a comedically spooky ad where a hockey mask wearing creep menacingly stalks through the forest… only to go to a DICK’S establishment to buy a top-of-the-line modern hockey mask, now far more safe than the original 1960s-era Jason mask. 

Tomcat

Tomcat isn’t a stranger to some more playfully grim ad campaigns, but I think it’s about time to lean entirely into the fear. The twist? Paint how this fear the mice feel is a good thing, as it clears your house of unwanted pests.

Trolli

Trolli definitely has a history of wonderfully strange adverts, most notably their stop-motion era beginning in 2019. I’d love for them to return to freakish cuteness with a Halloween campaign where the fun-loving Trolli curse spreads through a trick-or-treat street on the night of Halloween, fully leaning into a ‘The Thing’-esque psychological horror. Of course, getting possessed by the Trolli parasites is worth it when you get to eat this tasty sweet treat!

Why Are Brands Scared of Being Scary?

Kennon Cummings
·
November 12, 2026

Who I think should embrace the terror.

IT WAS A DARK AND STORMY NIGHT…

A young boy ventures out into the foggy maw that is the woods on the outskirts of his village. 

At this time, he’s not meant to venture this far out unmonitored, but the boy knows it’s for a valiant reason: his beloved dog had run astray under his watch. 

Suddenly, he hears a shrill whine. Following the cries of his pet, he stumbles upon something…. New.

A hole sits in the middle of the clearing. Ominous, pulsating, hungry for more. 

And suddenly— the boy is struck by a geyser…. Of tiramisu. 

…Did I mention this story is pulled straight from an overnight oats ad? 

‍

LET’S GET SCARY!!!!

Up-and-coming brand Oat Cult definitely shocked the masses with this ad showcasing their new flavored oats. It’s hard not to be surprised— amidst a wholesome, granola-girl-esque market of oatmeal products, a sinister cult-like twist sticks out like a sore thumb in the absolute best way possible. On top of the kooky, spooky vibe the brand usually sports, these borderline-horrifying ads feel novel even outside the world of breakfast food ads. 

So… why don’t we see out-of-left-field scares like this more often?

While fear is as potent an emotion as any other, it can be a feeling that’s difficult to harness effectively in advertising. Many brands can be a bit too worried about possibly scaring off potential customers with their ads, often going for safer emotional routes, like comedy or feel-good content.

I understand the worries… but honestly? It just makes me want brands to do it even more! When done effectively, you leave a lasting impression on your audience and stand out from the crowd. 

WHO SHALL JOIN THE SPOOKY ELITE?

Obviously, I need to enlist some troops to join the league of scary ads. I got three pitches for you today:

DICK’S Sporting Goods

I’m imagining a comedically spooky ad where a hockey mask wearing creep menacingly stalks through the forest… only to go to a DICK’S establishment to buy a top-of-the-line modern hockey mask, now far more safe than the original 1960s-era Jason mask. 

Tomcat

Tomcat isn’t a stranger to some more playfully grim ad campaigns, but I think it’s about time to lean entirely into the fear. The twist? Paint how this fear the mice feel is a good thing, as it clears your house of unwanted pests.

Trolli

Trolli definitely has a history of wonderfully strange adverts, most notably their stop-motion era beginning in 2019. I’d love for them to return to freakish cuteness with a Halloween campaign where the fun-loving Trolli curse spreads through a trick-or-treat street on the night of Halloween, fully leaning into a ‘The Thing’-esque psychological horror. Of course, getting possessed by the Trolli parasites is worth it when you get to eat this tasty sweet treat!

See More by

Kennon Cummings

→